Toilet clogs
Close the supply valve first. A toilet can only overflow as long as the tank keeps refilling.
Stop the overflow
The oval valve on the wall behind the toilet turns clockwise to close. If it won't move, lift the tank lid and hold the float up while someone finds the main shut-off, usually where the water service enters the basement near the meter.
Lay towels round the base. Water from a bowl that has not flushed yet is just tank water.
Plunging that works
- Use a flange plunger, the kind with a sleeve that fits into the bowl's outlet. A flat cup plunger seals poorly on a toilet.
- Leave enough water in the bowl to cover the rubber. Push down slowly the first time to push air out, then pump hard a dozen times.
- A closet auger, a short crank cable with a bent tube, reaches through the trap without scratching the porcelain if you keep the tube against the bowl.
Signs it isn't the toilet
Plunge the toilet and the tub gurgles, or water appears in the basement floor drain: the blockage is downstream, in the main. More plunging only pushes water out of the floor drain downstairs. Stop and read main sewer line clogs.
In a two-flat, a toilet upstairs that clogs every time the downstairs unit runs laundry also points to the shared drain, not the fixture.
What a plumber may do
Most toilet clogs clear with a closet auger. When something hard is stuck in the trapway, such as a toy, a phone or a toilet cleaner block, the toilet has to be lifted and the object pushed out from below. That means a new wax ring, so the visit takes longer.
Wipes sold as flushable, paper towels and cat litter are frequent causes. They pass the toilet and lodge further down, which is why the clog sometimes comes back days later.
Ask
- If the toilet has to come up, is a new wax ring and bolts part of the charge?
- If the auger finds nothing in the toilet, will they check the main from a cleanout?